Not sure if your social media is working? Here’s what to look out for and a monthly checklist to keep you on track.
Want to know how to measure social media success, and whether your posts are reaching potential customers? Our Social Media 101 guide to measuring success explains what each metric means, to tell if it’s working for you and provides you with a checklist to help you start creating content that performs.
Start by deciding what success looks like.
You can’t measure success until you’ve decided what it looks like. Most small businesses want one of these things from their social media:
- More enquiries or bookings
- Increase in people knowing who they are
- More online sales
Every business is different, with different goals, so there’s no single way to measure success. Once you know your goal and what you want for your business you will now know which metrics to focus on and which you can simply ignore.
Why likes don’t measure social media success any more
Platform algorithms are constantly changing, so is the way they reward content. Instagram’s head, Adam Mosseri, has said the signals that matter most are watch time and sends (people sharing your post by DM). Sends are the strongest signal for reaching people who don’t already follow you. Saves and profile visits also tell the platform your content was worth someone’s time.
Plenty of people still assume likes = successful content. We’re here to tell you that thinking is out of date. Likes still count, mostly with your existing followers but on their own they say very little about whether your content is working.
LinkedIn works in a similar way, how long someone spends on your post, along with comments and shares, decides how far the algorithm pushes it.
The social media metrics that matter
Here’s our simple overview of each metric and what it tells you:
| Metric | What it tells you | Where to find it |
| Shares | People enjoyed or related to this post so much they sent it to a friend | Post insights |
| Saves | People want to come back to this post | Post insights |
| Watch time | Your video either held attention or it didn’t | Reel insights |
| Profile visits | This post made someone curious about you | Account Insights |
| Comments and replies | A real conversation has started, and that’s how a community is built | Post insights and notifications |
| Link Clicks | Someone wanted to find out more | Account Insights |
If you want to help a post perform, reply to comments quickly. According to Sprout Social, around three-quarters of social media users expect a brand to reply within 24 hours, and Power Digital found that 76% feel more loyal to brands that reply to their comments and messages.
What about followers and likes?
Notice we didn’t include follower count or likes? That’s because they’re the numbers you shouldn’t be worrying about. Your follower count doesn’t reflect how well your business or your content is doing. And don’t get us started on bought followers, they’re a big red flag and will drag down the reach of everything you post. As for likes, they’re nice to see, but they won’t tell you whether your content is bringing in customers.
Your monthly social media checklist
Want to see if your content is successful and helping you achieve your goal? Follow our checklist below:
- Find your top three posts by shares and saves. What did they have in common
- For example, a person on camera, a behind-the-scenes moment or a useful tip
- Find your three worst-performing posts, the ones with the fewest shares and saves. What did they have in common?
- Look at your total profile visits and link clicks. Has this changed since the previous month, have they gone up or down since last month?
- Look at your enquiries, bookings and sales. Did anyone mention finding you through social media?
- Top tip: add a ‘How did you hear about us?’ tick box to your booking and order forms
- Go through your findings and pick one thing to keep doing and one thing to stop.
- For example, if behind-the-scenes content got lots of shares, keep posting it. If single image posts get no engagement, drop them.
We recommend recording your findings from this checklist in a document or spreadsheet every month, so you can compare what’s working and what isn’t. Give it three months of consistent posting before you judge the results. This gives the platforms time to learn who your content is for and put it in front of the right people.
Need a hand?
If you’re struggling to find the time to create content or you’re not sure what’s working, we can help. At Little White House Marketing, every client gets a monthly report built around these numbers, with no jargon, and a clear plan for what we’ll change next. We work with businesses across Bournemouth, Christchurch, Poole and the rest of the UK. So, if you’d like us to look after your accounts and find out what works for you, get in touch, we’re happy to help.
Sources:

